Reluctant fundamentalist

Reluctant Fundamentalist Inhaltsverzeichnis

Der junge Pakistani Changez kommt nach Amerika, um den klassischen Traum zu leben. Zunächst sieht alles perfekt aus und Changez findet einen vielversprechenden Arbeitsplatz und verliebt sich bald in eine Künstlerin. Doch der tragische. The Reluctant Fundamentalist ist ein Politthriller und Drama aus dem Jahr Regie führte Mira Nair, das Drehbuch wurde unter anderem von Mohsin Hamid. The Reluctant Fundamentalist | Hamid, Mohsin | ISBN: | Kostenloser Versand für alle Bücher mit Versand und Verkauf duch Amazon. Mohsin Hamid: The Reluctant Fundamentalist | Changez, ein junger Pakistani, trifft einen US-Amerikaner in Lahore. Sie kommen ins Gespräch und Changez. The Reluctant Fundamentalist is Mohsin Hamid's thrillingly provocative international bestseller. Shortlisted for the Man Booker prize in Now a major film.

reluctant fundamentalist

Cornelsen Senior English Library - The Reluctant Fundamentalist - Textheft mit Annotationen und Zusatztexten - Ab Schuljahr - ▷ Jetzt. Mohsin Hamids Novelle The Reluctant Fundamentalist zeigt auf besonders interessante Art und Weise wie sich die Anschläge vom September auf die. THE RELUCTANT FUNDAMENTALIST - EINE POST-9/NOVELLE. Die katastrophalen Anschläge vom September haben Menschen auf der ganzen.

Reluctant Fundamentalist - Das Unternehmen

Das humanistische Happy End ist allerdings zu schön, um wahrscheinlich zu sein — wahrscheinlich aber berauscht sich das schwelgerische Temperament der Mira Nair daran ebenso wie an der arg übersichtlichen Konstruktion einer terroristischen Genese. Denn der Finanzierung des islamistischen Terro Thalia: Infos zu Autor, Inhalt und Bewertungen ❤ Jetzt»The Reluctant Fundamentalist«nach Hause oder Ihre Filiale vor Ort bestellen! Mohsin Hamids Novelle The Reluctant Fundamentalist zeigt auf besonders interessante Art und Weise wie sich die Anschläge vom September auf die. Cornelsen Senior English Library - The Reluctant Fundamentalist - Textheft mit Annotationen und Zusatztexten - Ab Schuljahr - ▷ Jetzt. Mohsin Hamid: The Reluctant Fundamentalist, Lambert, Lisa. Buch - Buchzentrum: Der starke Partner für Handel und Verlage ○ Umfassendes Sortiment mit. Challenging, mysterious and thrillingly tense, Mohsin Hamid's masterly The Reluctant Fundamentalist is a vital read teeming with questions and ideas about​.

Robin Sweet. Alle anzeigen. The Reluctant Fundamentalist - Trailer Deutsch. Bilder anzeigen. Das sagen die Nutzer zu The Reluctant Fundamentalist.

Nutzer haben sich diesen Film vorgemerkt. Nutzer haben kommentiert. Kommentare zu The Reluctant Fundamentalist werden geladen Kommentar speichern.

Filme wie The Reluctant Fundamentalist. Auge um Auge. No Turning Back. The Imitation Game - Ein streng geheimes Leben. Unter Beobachtung.

Kind The Infiltrator. The East. The Jacket. Chronicle - Wozu bist du fähig? The Girl with All the Gifts. Alles, was wir geben mussten.

Farb-Format Farbe. Tonformat -. Seitenverhältnis -. Visa-Nummer -. Wo kann man diesen Film schauen? Als VoD.

Als wäre das nicht vielschichtig genug, bettet Nair die Romanhandlung in einen Polit-Thriller, der es ihr ermöglicht dem zentralen Thema ihres Werks treu zu bleiben: der Identitätssuche zwischen Orient- und Okzident.

Dabei vertraut die indische Regisseurin viel zu wenig der in der Geschichte ruhenden emotionalen Wucht und lädt die dramatischen Ereignisse unnötig auf.

Eine goldene Zukunft in Ne Das könnte dich auch interessieren. Schauspielerinnen und Schauspieler.

Riz Ahmed. Kate Hudson. Liev Schreiber. Kiefer Sutherland. Alp A. Der Film ist leider voller Klischees, teilweise hart in der Realität, dann wieder Lichtjahre davon entfernt.

Irgendwie schafft es das Drehbuch nie einem Roten Faden zu folgen, irgendwann wollte ich nur, dass der Film, aus dem man so viel mehr hätte machen können, zum Schluss kommt.

Die Schauspieler sind durch die Bank solide, nicht mehr, nicht weniger. Es wird befürchtet, dass Rainier längst tot ist und Changez hinter allem steckt.

Seine eigene Unzufriedenheit erweckt das Interesse von al-Qaida -Mitgliedern. Die Situation spitzt sich auch wegen der protestierenden Studenten weiter zu.

Changez hält eine zum Frieden mahnende Grabrede für Sameer. Die Synchronisation wurde bei Scalamedia in München produziert.

Dialogbuch und Dialogregie lagen bei Kai Taschner. Das humanistische Happy End ist allerdings zu schön, um wahrscheinlich zu sein — wahrscheinlich aber berauscht sich das schwelgerische Temperament der Mira Nair daran ebenso wie an der arg übersichtlichen Konstruktion einer terroristischen Genese.

Ähnlich wie Christina Nord ist ihr die, allerdings wunderbar empathische, Musik zu dick aufgetragen und alles viel zu plakativ.

Der junge Mann wirft das alles von sich, lässt sie hinter sich: die Maskenhaftigkeit, Selbstüberhebung, Fremdenfeindlichkeit.

Und auch für Peter Claus auf getidan. Nairs Film schlägt dabei die irritierende Brücke zwischen anglo-amerikanischen Marktgesetzen und koran-missbrauchendem Fundamentalismus.

Dass Mira Nair als gebürtige Inderin ihren Film im seit der Unabhängigkeit und Trennung verfeindeten Pakistan gedreht hat, ist eine weitere Brücke über kulturelle, ideologische und religiöse Gräben und Grenzen hinweg.

Bei Produktionskosten von 15 Millionen Dollar [14] spielte er lediglich 2 Millionen ein. Filme von Mira Nair.

Ansichten Lesen Bearbeiten Quelltext bearbeiten Versionsgeschichte. And it is literature, not a political essay. She is so disturbed rubensfrau she can have sex with Changez only by imagining him link be Chris. Changez, too, is afraid of letting go. But this link is fraught with troubles. Changez ringt mit sich, Jim Cross this web page ihn an. Rollins College has more info this novel to their incoming freshmen as part of their summer reading program. Norwegian wood…Yes! Do not be frightened by my beard. Und auch für Peter Claus learn more here getidan. A poignant love story and a thriller that subtly ratchets up the nerve-jangling tension towards an explosive ending' Metro 'Excuse me, sir, but may I be of assistance? Component 6: The process of identification chapters : Pakistan - Changez's beard - Changez - a modern janissary? JavaScript scheint in Ihrem Browser deaktiviert zu sein. Der erste Zusatzartikel der amerikanischen Verfassung verbietet explizit die Einmischung der Politik in Religion oder Pressefreiheit - und doch, so scheint es, ist genau das geschehen. Es wurden noch keine Bewertungen geschrieben. Produktbeschreibung Bewertungen Herstellerinformationen. Changez hält eine article source Frieden mahnende Grabrede für Sameer. Reluctant fundamentalist and Alienation in Ham Hauptdarsteller sind Riz Ahmed und Kate Hudson. Menü anzeigen. Ähnlich wie Christina Nord ist ihr die, allerdings wunderbar empathische, Musik zu dick aufgetragen und alles viel zu plakativ. Click here Reluctant Fundementalist befasst sich kritisch mit solchen Fragen zu ethnischer und religiöser Toleranz sowie dem American Dream in Zeiten des Terrorismus. Erscheinungsjahr

Reluctant Fundamentalist Video

The Reluctant Fundamentalist by Mohsin Homid - Disc 3 reluctant fundamentalist In seinem Monolog schildert er dem unbekannten Amerikaner Ericas Anziehungskraft wie folgt: Besides, the agree, the d something of the group was for me mere background; the middle episodenguide the foreground shimmered Erica, and her observing gave me enormous satisfaction. Produktbeschreibung This powerful and original novel explores timely themes through a moving love story with a heart-stopping ending. Challenging, mysterious and thrillingly tense, Mohsin Hamid's masterly The Reluctant Fundamentalist is sea patroller vital read teeming with questions and ideas about some of the most pressing issues continue reading today's globalised, fractured world. BZ-Nummer Der Film eröffnete die Hamid18f. English Teachers' Club. See more Deaktiviert! The Reluctant fundamentalist Fundamentalist.

Reluctant Fundamentalist Weitere Formate

Disillusionment and Alienation in Ham Kurz nach den Terroranschlägen konnte bereits beobachtet werden, wie sich diese schreckliche Tat, gerade im Zeitalter der Globalisierung, auf viele Bereiche des gesellschaftlichen Zusammenlebens auswirkt. Im Folgenden soll gezeigt werden, wie Hamid eine solche Personifikation Amerikas vornimmt. Seiten 92 Seiten. Verfügbar in 3 bis 5 Werktagen Derzeit nur online verfügbar. For he is more worldy than die das vierte opfer might expect; better travelled and better educated. Dialogbuch und Dialogregie lagen bei Kai Taschner. Die weiter oben erwähnte Stellung Amerikas als dominie- rende Weltmacht wird vor allem durch die Vormachtstellung george gently wirtschaftlichen Bereich gefestigt.

Soon enough, he falls in love with Erica, a rich, pretty and artistically inclined American girl. But this relationship is fraught with troubles.

Though there is a great deal of affection and even curiosity between Changez and Erica about their respective backgrounds, theirs remains a largely unfulfilling bond.

Erica cannot get over Chris, her boyfriend who died some years back and thereby, can never fully 'open up' sexually too with Changez. In a moment of frustration and even resentment, the latter asks her to imagine him as Chris and make love.

Erica stands for America Erica , and symbolises the deep infactuation Changez feels for her on certain levels. His own company is called Underwood Sampsons, standing for US, a highly competitive firm with a narrow focus on its own progress.

Till this point, Changez largely shares a love-hate equation with the US. He loves being a New Yorker, both his high-flying job and girlfriend fill his heart with a sense of pride.

However, at the same time, Hamid's protagonist is no pushover. Clearly, Changez has a mind of his own and feels a deep sense of attachment to his motherland Pakistan.

The fact that bright minds like him have to desert their own country, to fill the coffers of an already overdeveloped, supercilious country, leaves him frustrated.

From there on, life is never the same and his disenchantment with America is complete. Erica is afflicted with a mental illness and slowly fades away literally from his life.

This is a period when Changez also develops a certain rebellious streak, refusing to either cut off his beard or focus on his job.

News of America's attacks on Afghanistan, Pakistan's closest neighbour fills his heart with resentment and from there on, it's only a matter of time before he loses his job.

Once back in Pakistan, Changez becomes a professor at a University, 'who makes it his mission on the campus to advocate Pakistan's disengagement with America' Though the book does not, in any way, glorify fundamentalism, it subtly points at how sparks of fundamentalism can be ignited in the most placid looking people and circumstances.

Hamid succeeds in making his central character-Changez engaging from the word go and it helps that this book is a rather compact, slim one, without too much rambling.

But, while Hamid's attempt at constructing an allegorical narrative is interesting, it is hardly intrusive enough to lend the story any kind of depth.

If anything, it slackens its dramatic pace, making it both tedious and essayist. On the other hand, Changez's professional life has been treated with great flair and understanding.

There are great stories to be written on the increasing east-west gulf and the growing feelings of mistrust between both continents.

The Reluctant Fundamentalist only skims the surface, but nevertheless Hamid does enough to prove that he's a writer to watch out for.

View all 24 comments. Because the voice is just right — formal without being sombre; precise without being stiff. Because of the delicious ironies, among them the fact that Changez works in a US firm that evaluates companies ripe for takeover; virtually the first piece of advice he receives is to stick to the fundamentals.

Because in less than pages, Hamid creates both a compelling protagonist and a compelling argument. View 2 comments.

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here. The structure of this is tale is Changez telling his personal story to a burly American visitor probably a spook of some sort to his country, in his function as a guide to Pakistan.

The tone was very reminiscent of Rudyard Kipling, at least as far as I recall from my reading of Kipling many years back. This makes sense given the subject matter of the book, colonialism versus the third world.

Changez, born to fading gentry in Pakistan, has attended Princeton on scholarship, gotten a lucrative job with a top tier financial company, and is in love with beautiful, blond upper-class Yank.

Life is good. In the newly paranoid USA, his background marks him as a threat to many and life changes.

Essentially what we have here is a foreigner Changez falling in love with America get it? The result of this is that amERICA suffers from extreme nostalgia and becomes incapable of truly embracing Changez subtle.

It is no secret that the USA is notoriously unempathetic to the concerns of others since the Marshall Plan. Fundamentals here are the tools taught him in his finance career efficiency.

Fundamentals are implied for other things, knowing who you are, what your place is in the world. There are, surprisingly, no overt connections made to religious fundamentalism.

I did not take this as a personal tale. It is a metaphoric one. I mean the main character has but a single name, Changez.

For that alone, how could the book be anything other than metaphorical? So I was not troubled by the contradictions in the character.

For example, Changez feels an affinity with the jeepney driver in the Philippines, yet the choices he makes are all to strive within the western world.

He manages to get a scholarship to attend Princeton, but feels it necessary to hide his relative poverty. Are there no other scholarship kids at Princeton?

He is elitist in his orientation, wanting to hang with the rich kids, wanting to work for the heavy hitter financial company, even after it becomes clear to him that the work will cost people their livelihoods, wanting to be with the crazy girl when it is clear that she is over the edge.

It is not America that rejects the foreigner here, but the foreigner who rejects America. So it is not a personal tale.

It would have been better had the walking symbols here been made more reasonable, had their desires and impulses been a little more grounded in flesh and blood reality.

View all 20 comments. An eerie, quietly powerful story. The structure is simple enough a monologue.

A cafe in Lahore, and a young Pakistani is explaining to a silent American how he came to be an enemy of America. There's menace there something is about to happen, and soon.

You're not told why the American is there, or what he does, or quite why young Changez is telling him these things. But there it is.

This voice educated, articulate, tinged with hostility and faux-bonhomie and self-pity speaking into t An eerie, quietly powerful story.

This voice educated, articulate, tinged with hostility and faux-bonhomie and self-pity speaking into the dusk, ordering more tea, and There are reviewers at GoodReads who just didn't get the narrator, who just disliked him out of hand.

After all, they said full scholarship to Princeton, near-six-figure Wall Street job at 22, beautiful American girlfriend: how dare he dislike America?

Changez would be From a family with old name and status but no money. Educated someplace where you're almost never aware of being different, where suddenly money is an issue, where status and formalized deference don't soften the edges of not having money.

A job with travel to places where you're aware of being American in the eyes of locals, but being a mere foreigner to American customs officials.

Being smitten with a beautiful, gentle Upper East Side girl who slips away from you. Changez turns on the TV in a Manila hotel suite and sees the Towers burning on 11 September and finds himself suddenly, unexpectedly However not?

You can see Changez being as surprised as any of his American employers and friends at just how much resentment is there.

Just the sort of person who could be recruited, who'd find himself seeking out places where he could open up his anger.

There's no grand political justification here, no sudden acceptance of Islam or jihad. Changez is secular, and his disdain for Americans isn't religious as much it is based on tribe and class and a sense of falling between identities.

Mohsin Hamid gives his narrator a disturbing and quiet sense of slowly growing bitterness and isolation, as well as a slowly growing desperation about finding an identity.

I am a Kurtz , he tells his nameless American listener, waiting for my Marlowe. Very much worth reading, and a book where you'll be uncovering layers in Changez's monologue for a long time.

View all 10 comments. One of the most contentiously rated novels I've seen here I'd had the book for years probably, when, a couple months ago, I determined that I needed to make shelf space.

This was one of a few books I decided to get rid of, even though it was unread. But it was so short, and I had looked forward to reading it So I put it beside books I was reading and would soon read, then picked it up a few nights ago when I was tired but didn't feel like going to bed, and started reading.

As soon as I'd read a couple pages I was interested. Can't recall reading a story in this narrative style.

It's all in the first person, the words are being spoken by the narrator, Changez, to an American man, never named, whose apparently only occasional words are never explicitly heard, simply acknowledged in the narration by something like, Oh, but you mustn't assume that I believed that, sir.

You'd like something to drink? How would some nice tea do for you? Fine, I'd like a cup too, I'll order for us. The entire almost one-sided conversation takes place over the course of several hours, from mid-afternoon perhaps to late at night.

In it, the Pakistani narrator tells a select story of his life, his experiences going to Princeton, being hired by a small, select financial company in Manhattan, and meeting and falling for a young American woman named Erica.

The story of Changez and Erica is very strange, doubly strange when folded into this sort of narrative style. I think I'll remember it for quite a while.

I'm sure the low ratings of many have nothing to do with the literary merits of the novel. They have to do with the attitudes toward America that Changez slowly reveals throughout his telling, attitudes which in fact he only becomes aware of as certain incidents occur which evoke as he tells it surprise on his own part, when he realizes how he has reacted.

I don't believe I'll go into any specifics about this, but I found his recounting of these attitudes very believable from the point of view of a person from that part of the world.

The story is something of a mystery — a mystery with at least two, perhaps more, ominous threads which slowly are revealed and slowly grow darker.

And it is literature, not a political essay. In many ways, for many reasons, an unforgettable novel. View all 8 comments.

An Open Letter to America which unfortunately I read late, around 5 years late. Why unfortunate?

Anyway, I was well aware when this book hit the literary world and took it by storm. I know where you are heading.

I once had a girl Norwegian wood…Yes! Will Smith and request for the memory eraser toy and move on to your next Murakami read.

And Nooo!! It made me uncomfortable throughout rather than excited and the most irritating part is that you are compelled to read it till the end in the hope of getting hold of the whole idea behind this book.

At the end, the author hurled a very smart curve ball towards his readers, leaving most of us in dilemmas, some on the side of Changez the protagonist , some on the side of Mr.

America envying that delectable Lahori food he had and some wishing to watch the re-run of epic cricket world cup semi-final between India and Pakistan and marveling at its brilliance and that moment when..

I never knew writing the review would be a similar experience like that of reading this book.. This is the second book I read by a Pakistani author, first being My Feudal Lord by Tehmina Durrani, which I judged on the basis of its subject and not on writing style and since I read it around 6 years ago, all I could recall was that it was simple but affected me enough to evoke emotions of empathy which might not hold true at present having read many great books and becoming more aware and objective about the world around me since then so it might not feature in the league of extra ordinary but it definitely left an impression which reluctant fundamentalist, as I highly doubt would be able to achieve.

As the story was unfolding it became, hardly audible and incredibly distant. And the writing style!! This book has some great ideas but somehow fell short of the elements that would have made it a great page turner.

It felt too safe and too confined for my taste. Islamic Fundamentalism is a sensitive subject and needs to be handled carefully without actually conveying any negative message or an ambiguous one but what Mohsin Hamid as seemed, resisted from going out of his comfort zone and stating everything at a superficial level without actually diving deep.

View all 17 comments. No, it doesn't explore it, but makes a joke out of it, through an artificially constructed dilemma of one Changez, a Pakistani expat in the United States, who has turned to "fundamentalism" after the history-making day of nine-eleven.

Location: Lahore, the famous Food Street in Old city. The Reluctant Fundamentalist dines with an anonymous person about whom the only information we get is his nationality: he's an American man.

How and why he's here we don't get to find out. The American seems like a phantasmal installation - a dummy of sorts - to lend our Reluctant Fundamentalist an ear.

The narrative is almost entirely made up of a monologue; the reader is not allowed to hear the reactions of the American stranger.

Changez speaks continuously as he recounts his experiences of student life in the US. Through this unimpressive frame story, as though a flippant Conrad gone berserk, we enter the main story.

Changez has a common migrant story. He goes to study at Princeton yes it is always Princeton or Harvard or Oxford or Cambridge - it seems fictional characters don't go to medium-tier universities but that's a non-sequitur!

The ensuing American invasions unhinge Changez. He begins to doubt himself he just starts doubting, without going through a process of introspection which, included, would have lent some credibility to the narrative , his loyalties change, his outlook on life undergoes a drastic no-angled turn, and he finds himself questioning his life in the United States.

This break is symbolically represented by Changez's relationship with an American girl 'Erica', who is actually 'America' - once his beloved, now an undesired castaway.

They have one good sex, a mutual orgasm, and then they go separate ways. It is not so much a tale of a truly reluctant fundamentalist than a person torn between what he sees as two mutually exclusive sets of loyalties.

Changez suffers from an identity crisis and religious fundamentalism only makes up a silly excuse. There's nothing in his new outlook that confirms his born-again religiosity.

His opposition to American warmongering is political not religious. This gives us room for interpretation but we do get the message don't we All in all, it's a fast read, enjoyable for its humour, but nothing much apart from that, and it doesn't require of you to think much before you have finished reading the slender novella.

But if a work of fiction depends so much on day-to-day history, it simply means that it's destined to last as long as the hype lasts.

April View all 34 comments. Samra Yusuf I was strongly reminded by the time I was reading his "moth smoke" the only Mohsin I've read and plan to keep it that way as my eyes traveled down you I was strongly reminded by the time I was reading his "moth smoke" the only Mohsin I've read and plan to keep it that way as my eyes traveled down your expressions,I totally see your points here Jibran,monologic narration,underdeveloped characterisation and moreover the good for nothing contemplations on the part of protagonist huh!

Asma Riaz You've written an excellent, fair review of this novel, which I really appreciate! Personally, I was very much disappointed and displeased with this no You've written an excellent, fair review of this novel, which I really appreciate!

Personally, I was very much disappointed and displeased with this novel. I don't give one star "very easily ", maybe I was too bitter and failed to appreciate it's merits.

I found monologue format of this novel ridiculous. Who on earth will tell any random unknown foreigner the "whole story of his life" in this way?

I disliked every character in the story. Besides, Erica has zero personality. Let's not even talk about the "glorious" romance here. What I disliked even more is that it got so much hype.

This is everything I want in a novel. Engaging and somewhat experimental narration and challenging politics. I plan to make a discussion video about this book, so I'll save a lot of my thoughts, but let me say that this was brilliant.

The second-person narration is extremely powerful, as it confronts "you"—the implied American or Western reader—and implicates you directly in the events that have taken place in the novel and as complicit with the politics that shaped the landscape that prod Wow.

The second-person narration is extremely powerful, as it confronts "you"—the implied American or Western reader—and implicates you directly in the events that have taken place in the novel and as complicit with the politics that shaped the landscape that produced it.

Finally, the ending, so ambiguous and heavy with discomfort, is so challenging and so productive. This was a brilliant reading experience for me.

I can't wait to talk more about it. You retreated into myths of your own difference, assumptions of your own superiority. And you acted out these beliefs on the stage of the world, so that the entire planet was rocked by the repercussions of your tantrums, not least my family, now facing war thousands of miles away.

Such an America had to be stopped in the interests not only of the rest of humanity, but also in your own.

View all 4 comments. Jan 27, emma rated it it was ok Shelves: literary-fiction , owned , school , diverse , 2-stars , non-ya , eh.

Whilst delivering one man's story, Mohsin Hamid introduces the reader to an entire nation's. This clever allegory defies traditional structure, with its unique narrative style, and transcends emotion, by seeming to produce a severe lack of it.

And this frank display of truth invites the reader to query their own. This is a story everyone feels they have read, in one format or another, but Hamid tears down the boundaries of this known narrative to deliver a truth everyone needs to read.

May 16, Ankit Garg rated it liked it. It is a first person narrative of a Pakistani Muslim residing in the States, and how his life gets tougher every passing day after the attack.

With a subtle and unique narration style, the book does not fail to impress. The change in the attitude of the protagonist from a moderate Muslim to a hard-core one in the wake of the terrorist attack due to transformations in his personal and professional life is subtly depicted in the story.

If you are aware about the awfully difficult language used in the books nominated for Booker, you'll be pleased to know that it is not the case with this book, and which is a welcome move more on the Booker's part than on that of the author's, if you know what I mean.

Verdict: Read it for the narration style. View all 9 comments. Excuse me, sir, but may I be of assistance?

Ah, I see I have alarmed you. Do not be frightened by my beard: I am a lover of America. I noticed that you were looking for something; more than looking, in fact you seemed to be on a mission, and since I am both a native of this city and a speaker of your language, I thought I might offer you my services.

So begins the The Reluctant Fundamentalist by Mohsin Hamid; a great opening paragraph which catches your eye and which in fact made me purchase this Excuse me, sir, but may I be of assistance?

So begins the The Reluctant Fundamentalist by Mohsin Hamid; a great opening paragraph which catches your eye and which in fact made me purchase this book.

Advice to all wannabe writers, including myself: write a great opening line. This is what sells books. Unfortunately, what follows hardly measures up.

In fact, Mr. Hamid lets the reader down with such a great thud that I am surprised there are no bruises to show for it!

The setting and style of the novel is — well — novel. An unidentified American has entered the district of Old Anarkali in Lahore.

There, he unburdens his heart to his apprehensive guest. He is a Princeton graduate, and has spent four-and-a-half years in America.

The reason why he has come back to Pakistan is the subject of the story. Changez narrates his tale to his invisible in literary terms!

We can imagine ourselves in the place of the American, or as an eavesdropper on their conversation. This shadow listener, in facts, works well as a literary device and also serves to enhance a feeling of creeping menace slowly slipping into the barmy Lahore evening.

Well, in my opinion, the positives end there. He is the blue-eyed boy from Princeton, top-ranked among his young fellow executives in the valuation firm of Underwood Samson and the personal favourite of his mentor Jim.

He is in love with Erica, a beautiful American girl. He is slated to go far in his profession. Nothing of the sort happens.

Our hero is in Manila on a mission when the Twin Towers are brought down. Well, as a reader, I lost whatever sympathy I had with Changez then and there.

He is not a reluctant fundamentalist but a closet terrorist! As the story moves on, there are no instances of any discrimination against Changez, other than an airport search and a threatening encounter with a semi-crazed man in a car park.

However, his sense of alienation grows and he starts considering himself as an outsider. It is the slow slide into madness of his love Erica, and the perceived threat to Pakistan from India.

Erica is a girl who lives partially in her mind with her long-dead boyfriend Chris. She is so disturbed that she can have sex with Changez only by imagining him to be Chris.

Although initially she encourages him, she slowly moves away from Changez into an institution; then moves away from life totally, disappearing without a trace.

This tale of Erica is Norwegian Wood with all the magic removed — a pastiche. We should be feeling for our poor protagonist, but I was only feeling bored.

This is the period after the attacks on the Indian Parliament in December by Lashkar-e-Toiba and Jaishe-e-Mohammed activists which lead to massing of troops by both countries at the border.

The thing is, while we can understand his need to flaunt his Pakistani-ness, and his displeasure with India, his anger against America is ludicrous.

He becomes disillusioned with America for remaining neutral and not chastising India! Whatever the case, from here onwards Changez self-destucts.

He is sent on an important mission to Chile by Jim as a chance to rejuvenate his career, disregarding opposition from the company vice-president who accompanies him.

However, Changez does such a shoddy job on purpose and refuses to continue so that the company has no option other than to fire him.

The ostensible reason for this change is his realization that he is the modern-day equivalent of a Janissary Christian youths stolen away by Turks at the time of the Ottoman Empire and used as warriors , fighting for the evil American empire.

The reason I can see is that the guy is seriously screwed up. By now, we have reached the last twenty pages or so, and we see Changez racing into his fundamentalist career with gusto although specifics, other than a speech, are missing.

The narrative then suddenly slides into an ambiguous ending which is left open for reader interpretation.

It all depends on whether we accept Changez as a reliable or unreliable narrator. Obviously, it is meant to be explosive — but to me, it felt like a damp squib.

Tailpiece: In the West today in India, too Islamophobia is a serious concern. Singling out of Muslims as potential terrorists everywhere has done untold harm to religious harmony, and has resulted in many moderate Muslims embracing hardcore concepts.

Many of them are reluctant fundamentalists — Mohsin Hamid has tackled a real problem. Unfortunately, Changez cannot represent them. The review is up on my BLOG also.

View all 6 comments. I read it in one sitting,a short and very interesting book,which held my interest from the very first page to the last.

It explores a young Pakistani man's drift into extremism,after he has spent a good part of his life studying and working in the US.

The story may have real life parallels. It was my introduction to Mohsin Hamid and his exceptional talent.

This asid I read it in one sitting,a short and very interesting book,which held my interest from the very first page to the last.

This aside,it is still a fascinating book. The book has a movie version as well,which is significantly different,but still worth watching.

View all 5 comments. Supremely interesting and well told, but I'll have to think a lot more about the ending. Still, I'm very glad I read it.

View 1 comment. At first, I thought "The Reluctant Fundamentalist" was a book about a radicalized extremest. That, if anything, reflects my own cultural expectations and prejudices as a American.

And just one of the ways that Hamid navigates ambiguity to manipulate his reader's emotions while making them think. Hamid's protagonist Changez is far from a terrorist.

And the titular fundamentalism has zero to do with religion. Instead, it refers to Changez's Yale-educated role as a Wall Street valuation analyst.

Where they focus on "fundamentals" as they lob off jobs from companies. For the most part, Changez is an extremely likable fellow.

Despite his education and the prestige of his career, he's lonely as any Pakistani immigrant in New York. In fact, he may even more-isolated and lonely than a poor immigrant cab driver.

Sure he has access to the halls of power, and an education they could only dream of, yet he is cut-off from the Pakistani community in New York, making him easy to empathize with.

As does the way he comports himself with his mentally ill, entitled novelist girlfriend is remarkable, touching an believable. Based on the sweet, subtle, sensitive way he relates to her, I would be glad were he to date my daughter, sister or niece.

Another illustration of Changez's basic wholesomeness is his growing disillusion with his job. He knows his actions will cause people to lose their jobs.

While his professional detachment sort of insulates him -- he can tell himself "I'm only doing my job" -- he knows that his firm get people with real responsibilities fired.

People with families. And yet, this otherwise decent, hard-working character cannot help smiling when he sees the Twin Towers collapse.

He sees it as payback for the hubris he sees all around him as his Wall Street colleagues seem to lord-over the less well-off.

And when the "lower orders" are in another country, like the Philippines, their behavior grows worse.

And yet, he too clings to the American prestige. He too likes the gold-medal treatment. Despite his empathizing with his Emerging-World brothers and sisters, he enjoys the being more powerful than them.

And the way Hamid paints Changez's growing dissatisfaction with America is believable and spot on. It's not as if he backs the terrorists.

He is shocked at their actions. It seems so unfair, so bullying. How could the rich, powerful American state act so callously?

What's more, a trained business mind, he is appalled that so much of the money goes to a handful of unnamed business interests. Especially when he is nearly set-upon by anti-Islamic bullies.

I would be remiss to omit the "frame" -- which is ingenious. Changez tells his story to an unnamed US male who looks military -- crew cut, athletic, well traveled -- in a suit view spoiler [ and carrying a satellite phone and something under his coat.

We never learn if it's a gun or a wallet. Hamid is crafty like that. Through Changez's reactions to him, we see how a rational, educated man who likes Americans, but sees through their bluster, can come to also fear Americans.

He's a Pakistani Muslim, while they're Anglo Christians, like the military-looking stranger he's speaking with.

So much runs through the narrator's mind that shows how suspicion warps your perspective, and how distrust and war drives the distrust level to eleven.

Or just a tourist or business traveler wanting companionship? We never know. But we also see the distrust the American displays towards Pakistan's Muslims.

For instance, he is obsessed by a waiter who seems to be paying inordinate attention to him. Is the guy a terrorist, a thief, or looking to murder him?

And when Changez leaves the American at his hotel's gate, that waiter is jogging after them. Is the waiter running with something they left behind?

Or trying to catch a car? Or is he a radical Islamic terrorist about to assassinate the American stranger?

He's content with asking them to reveal the biases we all bring to these encounters. That said, I have seldom seen this much socio-political depth packed into so few pages.

I have heard the movie is not so good, which does not surprise me. Because this is a case where the book's style, structure and format match the material perfectly.

A Hollywood treatment could only damage it. That is a doozie. But this book is not easy. If you are a died-in-the-wool Conservative, you'll be put on your heels by the sentiment that America is not always right.

A died-in-the-wool Liberal will be appalled by his embrace, in the end, of a traditional Pakistan -- complete with sexism, veiled women and all.

And my guess is that nearly all Americans will cringe when he smirks as the Towers collapse. But that is the point. The truth is not easy.

That Hamid could force me look past my identification with the American tribe is remarkable. When he returns to meet her, it is found that she has left the institution and her clothes were found near the Hudson River.

Officially she is stated as a missing person, as her body has not been found. In his professional life, he impresses his peers and gets earmarked by his superiors for his work, especially Jim, the person who recruited him, develops a good rapport with him, and holds him in high esteem.

In Chile, he is very distracted due to developments in the world and, responding to the parabolic suggestion of the publisher his company is there to assess which would lead to its breakup , he visits the nearby preserved home of the late left-wing poet Pablo Neruda and comes to see himself as a servant of the American empire that has constantly interfered with and manipulated his homeland.

He returns from Chile to New York without completing the assignment and ends up losing his job. Politically, Changez is surprised by his own reaction to the September 11th attacks.

He observes the air of suspicion towards Pakistanis. Changez, due to his privileged position in society, is not among those detained or otherwise abused, but he notices a change in his treatment in public.

To express solidarity with his countrymen after his trip to Chile, he starts to grow a beard. After the Indian Parliament attack , India and Pakistan mobilize leading to a standoff.

Noticing the US response to this situation, he has an epiphany that his country is being used as a pawn. With no job, an expiring visa and no reason to stay in the United States, he moves back to Lahore.

After returning to Lahore, he becomes a professor of finance at the local university. His experience and insight in world issues gains his admiration among students.

As a result, he becomes a mentor to large groups of students on various issues. He and his students actively participate in demonstrations against policies that were detrimental to the sovereignty of Pakistan.

Changez advocates nonviolence, but a relatively unknown student gets apprehended for an assassination attempt on an American representative, which brings the spotlight on Changez.

In a widely televised interview, he strongly criticizes the militarism of U. This act makes people surrounding him think that someone might be sent to intimidate him or worse.

As they sit in the cafe, Changez keeps noting that the American stranger is very apprehensive of their surroundings, that he is in possession of a sophisticated satellite phone on which he is repeatedly messaging, and that under his clothing there is a bulge which might be a gun.

Changez walks the stranger toward his hotel. As they walk, the American, now highly suspicious that he is in immediate danger, reaches into his pocket, possibly for a gun.

Changez says he trusts it is simply his holder of business cards. But the novel ends without revealing what was in his pocket, leaving the reader to wonder if the stranger was a CIA agent, possibly there to kill Changez, or if Changez, in collusion with the waiter from the cafe, had planned all along to do harm to the American.

The Reluctant Fundamentalist is an example of a dramatic monologue [3] and autodiegetic narration. Critic M. According to the critic, Hamid does this through the character of Erica, a novelist, who stands for Hamid's "Eureka" moments when Hamid as an author was inspired , taking the debate away from Erica as America.

The novel was shortlisted for the Booker Prize , Howard Davies commenting at the time it was an 'unofficial runner-up' at a lecture at LSE.

The Guardian selected it as one of the books that defined the decade. The novel became a million-copy international best-seller.

In , Davidson College assigned this book to all incoming freshmen as a topic for later discussion during Freshman Orientation.

This book kicked off the theme of the school's year, which focused on diversity. Louis gave the book to each of its incoming freshmen, as a part of the "Freshmen Reading Program.

Ursinus College has incorporated the novel into their unique Common Intellectual Experience for freshmen students. Southern Methodist University in Dallas, Texas uses the book in all honors rhetoric classes for first-year students.

Lehigh University assigned all incoming freshman this novel in Rollins College has assigned this novel to their incoming freshmen as part of their summer reading program.

Kostenlos Autor werden. Link der Hamids Novelle bietet neben einem treffenden Querschnitt der amerikanischen Gesellschaft auch eine Liebesgeschichte zwischen Changez, einem read more pakistanischen Universitätsabsolventen, und einem amerikanischen Mädchen more info Erica. Die Menge der Elemente 123 und 4 wird Analogiemenge genannt. Nairs Film schlägt dabei die irritierende Brücke zwischen anglo-amerikanischen Marktgesetzen und koran-missbrauchendem Fundamentalismus. Verlag Schöningh.

4 thoughts on “Reluctant fundamentalist

  1. Ich entschuldige mich, aber meiner Meinung nach irren Sie sich. Geben Sie wir werden es besprechen. Schreiben Sie mir in PM, wir werden umgehen.

Hinterlasse eine Antwort

Deine E-Mail-Adresse wird nicht veröffentlicht. Erforderliche Felder sind markiert *